Thursday, September 24, 2009

The call to prayer

My favorite part about Marrakech was appreciating the end of Ramadan. Every evening we would go on top of the roof of our friends' hostel, where you could see the whole city and the mountains stretching beyond it, and listen to the call to prayer as the sun went down. In Rabat, you hear the call from the nearest mosque; in Marrakech there are so many mosques that it sounds like an incomprehensible drone that overwhelms you from every side. It sounds more like a horror movie than a call to worship, and some mosques even set of sirens to rush to prayer. It's completely foreign and very surreal, and launched a really interesting argument between Tyler, who is guided by a combination of Marx and Chomsky, and Alice, who is an American that grew up in Saudi. Tyler's point, that I really agree with, is that there is no way to escape Islam if you live here. The call to prayer is a constant reminder, 10 times a day, that you have to follow social norms. To an outsider, it feels oppressive and dominating, and I'm sure that it has contributed to the 99% Muslim population more so than how truthful the religion is.

On the other hand, American culture has just as narrow of a worldview, but it is one of capitalism and the constitution. The constitution is to be held above all other laws, and we have a tribunal to interpret what the founders' intentions were and how to live our lives by their wisdom. We cannot adopt a law that is more suited to our time if it does not follow the guiding principles set by our democratic ancestors. We take this word above our own value judgments, using it to determine womens' rights and voting rights, even things like the consensus and states-rights of DC. We forget that it is man that wrote it, and somehow think that if we can get in an amendment banning gay marriage it will enshrine it as morally correct for all eternity. Capitalism too, is a value ingrained in our society and it is impossible to function without believing in it. Even in the current health care debate, we are more afraid of a law that might harm the capitalist system and threaten the safety of private companies than we are of human lives. It is politically risky (though thankfully becoming less so) to defend the right to our own health over the right of capitalism to profit from our sickness. Capitalism and the constitution are enforced by the media, by our families, our teachers, our politicians and our friends. I'm not saying this is a bad thing, I'm just saying that I'm starting to become more aware of how restrictive our society is, one which claims to be guided by choice and so escapes judgments of the human rights community.

So Alice's point was to take a step back and start to make a more objective evaluation. On the one hand, the Arab World is guided, almost without choice, by Islamic values and the Koran. This requires that you give 10% of your income to charity, support your family in times of trauma, and giving to the community. On the other hand, America is guided, almost without choice, by Democratic values and the Constitution. This requires that you become independent as early as possible, and advance your own career. Which set of guiding principles does more good in the world?

This morning was the first day since I arrived five weeks ago that I didn't wake up at 4am to the call to prayer. I guess I've gotten so used to it, I don't even hear it any more.

No comments:

Post a Comment